How to Fact-Check AI Answers at Work
Check an AI answer with a completed three-claim example, source conditions and a conversion-rate calculation you can reproduce.
By DailySignal.app · Published 2026-10-04 · Updated 2026-10-19
Check the claims somebody will rely on. Prices, deadlines, product features, quotations and performance figures deserve more scrutiny than a rough brainstorming suggestion.
You don't need to give every sentence the same treatment. Start with the detail that could change a decision, then find the evidence for the wording you actually plan to use.
One sentence can contain three different problems
Imagine a fictional AI draft: 'The tool costs $49 monthly, includes unlimited exports and cuts reporting time by 40%.' Your review finds that $49 is an annual-billing equivalent, exports have a plan limit and there is no relevant evidence for the 40% claim.
A usable revision is: 'The advertised price is equivalent to $49 a month when billed annually. Check the plan's export allowance before testing it. We haven't established a time saving for our reporting task.' Keep the actual source and plan conditions with that wording.
The price page cannot verify all three claims at once. Splitting them makes the correction manageable and stops a correct-looking number from lending credibility to an unsupported promise.
Open the source and read its conditions
Use the source best placed to establish the claim: current vendor terms for a feature, the issuing organization for a rule, the original study for its findings, or approved records for your own results.
Find the supporting passage and read its context. Check the date, plan, geography, version and measurement period where relevant. A working link establishes that a page exists; it doesn't establish that the draft described it accurately.
If the source is missing or inaccessible, mark the claim unresolved or remove it. Don't substitute a similar-looking citation and retain the original conclusion.
Reproduce the calculation
In this teaching example, 120 orders from 4,000 sessions is a 3% conversion rate: 120 divided by 4,000. Compared with 2%, that's a one-percentage-point increase and a 50% relative increase. 'Up 1%' leaves the reader guessing which you mean.
Check the period, filters and definitions before the arithmetic. Correct division doesn't make two different reporting windows comparable. Save the inputs and formula so someone else can repeat the check.
Check what became stronger in the summary
A source saying a feature 'may help' under certain conditions shouldn't become a promise that it will improve everyone's productivity. Preserve the qualification next to the claim it limits.
For quotations, locate the exact wording and speaker in the approved original. If the draft is a paraphrase, remove quotation marks and attribute it accurately. Don't repair a missing quote with something the person might plausibly have said.
Keep a small review record
One row per material claim is enough: original wording, best source, relevant conditions, status and correction or owner. Use supported, contradicted or unresolved as statuses. A deadline doesn't turn unresolved evidence into support.
AI can help prepare this list. Ask it to identify checkable claims and missing evidence, then verify the sources yourself. Agreement between two models isn't independent evidence of the underlying fact.
NIST's Generative AI Profile discusses confabulation and related risks. The workflow here is a practical editorial method, not a certification or a substitute for qualified review where the consequences require it.
Finish with usable wording
Read the final version once more. Check that its source links, figures and qualifications survived editing. Record what remains unresolved and who needs to review it before the next action.
Take one AI answer you intend to use today and check its three most consequential claims. Then use the decision-brief guide to turn the supported findings into a useful next step.
Put the checked evidence to work in a short decision brief.